Fundamentals 8 min read

Automatic Substitutions and the Vice-Captain: Exactly How FPL Settles Your Team

By Geomi George · Published 14 November 2026

Two rules decide what happens when a player you picked does not play: automatic substitutions and the vice-captain. Most managers have a rough idea of both and are still surprised several times a season. This guide states the rules exactly, works through the cases that cause the surprises, and explains how to set a bench and a vice-captain so the rules work for you.

When the rules apply

Nothing is substituted during a gameweek. The official game applies automatic substitutions and the vice-captain switch after the round's final match, as part of the same processing that confirms bonus points. Until then your live score is simply the eleven you started, which is why a team's total and league position can jump a day after the football has finished. A player counts as having played if he was on the pitch for any length of time; a single minute is enough.

Automatic substitutions, step by step

  1. Find the starters who did not play. Only a starter with zero minutes is replaced. A starter who played and scored nothing, or was sent off for a negative score, stays in your team.
  2. A goalkeeper can only be replaced by your bench goalkeeper, and only if the bench goalkeeper played.
  3. Outfield players are replaced in bench order. The game takes the first player on your bench and asks whether he played. If he did, it tries to bring him on for a missing starter. Then it does the same with the second and the third.
  4. The formation must stay legal. After any substitution your eleven must still contain one goalkeeper, at least three defenders, at least two midfielders and at least one forward. If bringing a bench player on would break that, he is skipped and the next one is tried.

The substitution is never chosen for points. The game does not look at who scored most on your bench; it follows your order. A bench player on twelve points stays on the bench if a team-mate ahead of him in the order played and fits.

The cases that catch people out

The formation blocks the substitute you wanted

Suppose you play 3-4-3 and one of your three defenders does not play. Your first substitute is a midfielder who scored eight; your second is a defender who scored two. The midfielder cannot come on, because that would leave you with two defenders. The game moves to the defender, and you get two points, not eight. The reverse also happens: if you play 5-3-2 and a defender misses out, any outfield substitute can replace him, because four defenders is still legal.

Two starters miss, one substitute played

Each bench player can come on once. If two starters did not play and only one outfield substitute did, one gap is filled and the other scores zero.

The substitute did not play either

A bench player with zero minutes is passed over, whatever his position in the order. This is the real cost of a bench made of the cheapest players in the game: they are cheap because they do not play.

Your starter came on for the last minute

He played, so he is not replaced. You keep his one appearance point and your bench stays where it is. A late cameo from a doubtful starter is the worst outcome of all, and a reason to bench a real doubt yourself when you have a reliable alternative.

The vice-captain

Your captain's points are doubled. If your captain plays no minutes at all in the gameweek, the double moves to your vice-captain. If the captain plays, even briefly and even for nothing, the armband stays with him and the vice-captain scores as an ordinary player. If neither of them plays, nobody is doubled.

The Triple Captain chip follows the same rule: if the captain does not play, the vice-captain's score is tripled. In a double gameweek, a captain who plays in either of his team's two matches has played.

Chips change the picture

With the Bench Boost all fifteen players score, so there is nobody to bring on and no automatic substitution takes place. With the Free Hit the rules apply to your one-week squad in the normal way. When to use each is covered in Chip Strategy.

Setting your bench and armband properly

How this site handles it

Because the official game applies these rules a day or so after the last match, a mini-league table read in between is wrong for anyone with a non-playing starter. Our mini-league tables apply the same substitution and vice-captain rules to every squad as soon as the matches are over, and mark the result "Not final yet" until the official figures replace it. When we introduced this we checked our calculated scores against the game's processed scores for 200 managers in one league, 110 of whom had a substitution or a captain switch that week, and all 200 matched. Any manager's team for any gameweek, with its substitutions listed, can be opened from the league table, and the full scoring behind each player is explained in The FPL Scoring System Explained.

G
About the author
Geomi George is the founder of FPL Elite and a long-time Fantasy Premier League manager. He builds the data tools on this site and writes its weekly gameweek analysis. Questions or corrections? Get in touch.

Read next